If the authors feel that they have a strong scientific case for reconsideration (if the referees have missed the point of the paper, for example) they can appeal the decision in writing. Second reason: methodological approach and results. Most referees honour their prior agreement with Nature to deliver a report within seven days or other agreed time limit, and send their reports online. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. //-->Nature (journal) - Wikipedia The first step in making the right decision is recognizing the problem or opportunity and deciding to address it. If so, how close was it? [CDATA[> The Cambridge Grammar Of The English Language [PDF] [39mcl5ibdiu0] Languages English Espaol Portugus Research Creative My Account Submit My Manuscript Answered by Editage Insights Decisions by editors are routinely made very rapidly after receipt of reports, and Nature offers an advance online publication (AOP) service to an increasing number of manuscripts. Can airtags be tracked from an iMac desktop, with no iPhone? How do I align things in the following tabular environment? In light of their advice, I am delighted to say that we can in principle offer to publish it in Nature, provided that you revise the paper to address a number of further editorial points. But in June 2022, the journal was removed from SCI indexing, what can i do, so much of work in it with two revsions taking more than a year,what can be done, Why is a PhD essential to become a peer-reviewer. You can appeal to the editorial board, giving a point-by-point argument against the editors views. Can we write a courteous mail asking about the status change from 'Decision Made' to 'Under Consideration'? At each stage, the editor will discuss the manuscript with editorial colleagues in the light of referees reports, and send a letter to the author offering one of the following options: Editors letters also contain detailed guidance about the papers format and style where appropriate (see below), which should be read in conjunction with the manuscript formatting guide when revising and resubmitting. Hi! Decisions, decisions | Nature Neuroscience Do roots of these polynomials approach the negative of the Euler-Mascheroni constant? Decision in progress means all the reviews have already been received and whats left is for the editor to make a decision. resubmitnoveltyappeal, Resubmitpoint-by-pointresponse letterresubmitresponse letterresubmitresponse letternature, Proofreadingresubmit, Proofreadinglicence to publish, NatureNatureNature, wileynature science, Nature CommunicationsNatureNature CommunicationsPeer-review, Nature Communicationstransparent peer-reviewgetNature Communicationsget50%Nature Communicaitons, sciencenature. or help with writing to the journal, you may find this handbook useful: How to communicate with the journal? Could you please shed some light on the outcome of your situation? If the reviewers wish to be named their names will appear in alphabetical order at the end of the paper in a statement as below: Any reviewers that wish to remain anonymous will be acknowledged using a slightly modified statement: If no reviewers agree to be named, we will still acknowledge their valuable service using the statement below: Nature makes decisions about submitted papers as rapidly as possible. Did this satellite streak past the Hubble Space Telescope so close that it was out of focus? Rejections based on serious errors are frustrating for authors and damaging to the journal's credibility, and so we have a procedure for reconsidering decisions at the author's request. How long should we wait if the current status of the manuscript is What does the status 'under editor evaluation' mean? and JavaScript. Improve this answer. If authors wish to contest an editorial decision, we ask them to submit a form that organizes their arguments into categories that we find useful in reviewing our original judgments. Of these, about 100 came in as presubmission enquiries by e-mail (for which our median decision turnaround time is 3 days). [CDATA[// >Editorial process : Springer Support Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative, Nature Neuroscience (Nat Neurosci) The journal opened for submissions on April 20, 2016. if you strongly disagree with the editorial decision, you can appeal against it unless the editor has clearly specified otherwise. #AcademicChatter" Read the entire letter, including all of the reviewers comments and the editors explanations (if any). How long should I wait for a response from the journal? Since then we have received nearly 600 manuscripts and presubmission enquiries. However, if it has not gone through peer review, but is directly showing the status awaiting final decision, then there is a possibility that your paper might be rejected after initial screening by the editor. This stage includes checks on authorship, competing interests, ethics approval and plagiarism. Sovereignty - Wikipedia What does this mean and should I contact the editor? Although optional, the cover letter is an excellent opportunity to briefly discuss the importance of the submitted work and why it is appropriate for the journal. [CDATA[> Thus a successful appeal requires convincing the editors that the original decision was a serious mistake, not merely a borderline call that could have gone either way. Things just always take much longer than we think they would. This will reduce delays. Improve the chances of your manuscripts acceptance by learning how to prepare a manuscript for journal submission and handle the peer review process. All Articles published in Nature go through at least one round of review, usually two or three, sometimes more. n/a. Does "editor decision started" mean rejection in Nature journals? Often, Editors reject the manuscript because the analytical approach is not sufficiently rigorous, explicit and argued, or because the results are barely significant or representative. Special care is given to papers whose authors native language is not English, and special attention is given to summary paragraphs. Thus, in rejecting an appeal, we do not intend to imply that our initial decision was flawless, only that the arguments for reconsideration were not sufficiently convincing to exceed the deliberately high threshold for reversing a decision. This website is using a security service to protect itself from online attacks. - 9.3 weeks. Either rejection or sending it out for review. you're still in the running. b. I regret giving them his address. A vital, and often overlooked, aspect of peer review is that in the current system, peer reviewers are normally not paid for their work. In a perfect world, we would consult with dozens of experts, who would spend many hours considering every point in the manuscript. Until then, you may find it worthwhile to go through the following resources about journal statuses: Answered by Irfan Syed The criteria for publication of scientific papers (Articles) in Nature are that they: Further editorial criteria may be applicable for different kinds of papers, as follows: Articles published in Nature have an exceptionally wide impact, both among scientists and, frequently, among the general public. Calm down, and wait a few days before starting your response, then re-read the version of the paper that you actually submitted. This scheme only applies to original research Articles, and not to Review articles or to other published content. This structured form allows us to evaluate the issues more efficiently, and we hope it will also help authors focus their arguments, and perhaps even recognize when they are wasting their time. Will contact my PI if it doesn't change to "decision sent to author" in the next few days. If an author wishes to appeal against Nature's decision, the appeal must be made in writing, not by telephone, and should be confined to the scientific case for publication. The editor will then decide whether to accept your work as is, request minor or major revisions, or reject the paper due to unresolvable concerns. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Locate submission instructions for a Springer journal, Submit a manuscript with your ORCID number, Submit a Nature Portfolio manuscript for Open Access publishing, Submit multimedia files to be published online with your article.